Supreme Court: Obama Had No Constitutional Authority for NLRB Recess Appointments

The Obama Administration took another hit Thursday when the Supreme Court unanimously ruled that his NLRB recess appointments were lacking in Constitutional Authority. 

The Court ruled that the recess appointment powers of the President were limited to high level vacant positions and those positions could be filled by the President as temporary appointments. 

The Justices rejected Obama's assertions that the Senate was in recess when he made his appointments.  The opinion states:

...we find that the pro forma sessions were sessions for purposes of the Clause. First,
the Senate said it was in session. The Journal of the Senate and the Congressional Record indicate that the Senate convened for a series of twice-weekly “sessions”
from December 20 through January 20. 2011 S. J. 923– 924; 158 Cong. Rec. S1–S11. (The Journal of the Senate for 2012 has not yet been published.) And these reports of
the Senate “must be assumed to speak the truth.” Ballin,
supra, at 4.


Second, the Senate’s rules make clear that during its pro forma sessions, despite its resolution that it would conduct no business, the Senate retained the power to conduct business. During any pro forma session, the Senate could have conducted business simply by passing a
unanimous consent agreement.

The Court also addressed political conflict regarding appointments:

....the Recess Appointments Clause is not designed to overcome serious institutional friction. It simply provides a subsidiary method for appointing offi­cials when the Senate is away during a recess.

This Supreme Court opinion reaffirms a lower court ruling:

we conclude that the Recess Appointments Clause does not give the President the constitutional authority to make the appointments here at issue. Because the Court of
Appeals reached the same ultimate conclusion (though for reasons we reject), its judgment is affirmed.


It is so ordered.

The entire Opinion:

Supreme%20Court%20Opinion%20Obama%20Recess%20Appointments.pdf

by:
Dee Lutz
Administrator
Tea Party Command Center

Views: 620

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Has the Supreme Court really woke up? Don't think so. Not yet. Does not the President have some of his own people in the Supreme Court now?

Thank God the Supreme Court has finally begun to exercise its Constitutional authority. If only now they will strike down the Executive Orders that Obama thinks give him authority to be DICTATOR whenever he thinks he can command the military to obey Martial Law Orders and arrest Congress and the Supreme Court — and all us constitutional conservatives and Tea Party as "enemies of the State" — HIS state!! 

NOW MY BIG QUESTION IS: WHAT ARE THEY GOING TO DO ABOUT HIS ILLEGAL APPOINTMENTS ALREADY CRIMINALLY MADE???? ARE THEY GOING TO REPEAL THEM OR WHAT??

Now, not one thing will change, Obama will just wait until the senate is out and reappoint the same people, the congress as usual will do nothing to change any thing the illegal appointees did. More smoke and mirrors.
My thoughts on this are that this is just the tip of the Iceberg of what Obama has done which were not Constitutional!

It is about time that the Supreme Court makes some sensible decisions. However, the admin probably does not care one way or the other.  They will just continue doing their nefarious, illegal activity as usual.

How refreshing...I wonder if the king's Teflon is finally wearing thin.Now how about the stack of other violations of our Constitution...programs and acts that should all be considered null and void ? If only Obama cared what the law states, or how SCOTUS rules.

The GOP is afraid to do anything about anything for fear that the libtards will come out in droves for the midterms.......They need to start doing the right thing --- not sue, IMPEACH !

Another one that the Supreme Court got right! FINALLY! Hope they don't stop here!

Now that the Supreme Court knows how to stand-up against Obama and his ruthless doing as he pleases, the Supreme Court now can abolish the OBC policy and get our beloved country back on track again.  I can't see how the Court can continue to back a bill which has changed more then 35 or more times.  It's plain to see that the bill passed is not the bill inflicted on the men, women and children of our wonderful country.  Obama broke it and he must be impeached and let us get it back to it's original Constitutional rulings. 

Muslim Dictator Obama has gone too far too many times!   It's going to catch up with him, I hope, very soon!

So, after all this what is the Congress going to do? Will they remove appointees or again cave in to Obama's rules?

RSS

LIGHTER SIDE

 

Political Cartoons by AF Branco

Political Cartoons by AF Branco

ALERT ALERT

Joe Biden Vows: Give Taxpayer-Funded Obamacare To All Illegal Aliens In U.S.

Former Vice President and 2020 Democrat presidential primary candidate Joe Biden is vowing to give Obamacare, funded by American taxpayers, to all 11 to 22 million illegal aliens living in the United States.

During an interview with Telemundo’s Jose Diaz-Balart, Biden forgot that Obamacare technically bans illegal aliens from enrolling in healthcare plans — although illegal aliens are still able to obtain subsidized and free healthcare at Americans’ expense — and promised that under his plan, all 11 to 22 million illegal aliens would be able to get Obamacare.

The exchange went as follows:

DIAZ-BALART: When I … NBC moderated that first debate with you, I didn’t … I don’t recall a clear answer, under your plan should … would the 11, 12 million undocumented immigrants that live in the United States, that have been here many for generations, would they have access …

BIDEN: Yes.

DIAZ-BALART: — to health insurance.

BIDEN: Yes, they … if they can buy into the system like everybody else.

DIAZ-BALART: Because you know, in [Obamacare] they can’t.

BIDEN: Yeah. Yeah, I know. Well they can, that’s my point. They continue to be able to do that.

DIAN-BALART: They cannot under the ObamaCare.

BIDEN: Well and that’s my point, they will though. They will be able to buy into … [illegal aliens] would be able to buy in, just like anyone else could.

Biden joins Sen. Bernie Sanders (I-VT), Sen. Elizabeth Warren (D-MA), and South Bend, Indiana, Mayor Pete Buttigieg — among other 2020 Democrats — in committing to forcing American taxpayers to pay for healthcare for illegal aliens who arrive in the U.S.

Already, due to loopholes, American taxpayers are spending nearly $20 billion every year to provide illegal aliens with subsidized healthcare, emergency room visits, and other health services.

Under the 2020 Democrats’ plan to provide taxpayer-funded healthcare to all illegal aliens living in the U.S., Americans would be billed potentially $660 billion every decade just to cover the costs. Other research has found that the plan would cost Americans at least $23 billion every year.

As Breitbart News has reported, experts have said that giving taxpayer-funded healthcare to effectively all foreign nationals who can make it to America’s borders would drive “strong incentives for people with serious health problems to enter the country or remain longer than their visas allow in order to get government-funded care.”

Despite 2020 Democrats’ continued push for taxpayer-funded healthcare for illegal aliens, American voters are overwhelmingly opposed to the plan. The latest Wall Street Journal/NBC News survey revealed that the healthcare-for-illegal-aliens plan is the least popular policy position, with opposition from 62 percent of U.S. voters.

Similarly, a CNN poll from July discovered that 63 percent of likely swing voters oppose providing healthcare to illegal aliens, along with nearly 6-in-10 of all likely U.S. voters and 61 percent of moderates. A Rasmussen Reports survey also found that likely voters, by a majority of 55 percent, oppose giving healthcare to even the most low-income illegal aliens.

Infantilization of Popular Culture

© 2019   Created by Steve - Ning Creator.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service