Arizona told to stop prosecuting job-seeking (illegal) immigrants

A federal judge ordered an immediate halt Monday to Arizona’s enforcement of identity theft laws that penalize immigrants in the country illegally for seeking employment.

U.S. District Judge David G. Campbell said in his order that the laws are at odds with federal statutes that protect such immigrants from prosecution simply for applying for work.

Federal law makes it a crime to use falsified documents, but draws a distinction between identity theft and application to work. The application to work by an immigrant in the country illegally is not, in itself, a crime under federal law.

Arizona tried to change that. In bills passed in 2007 and 2008, Arizona changed the definition of identity theft to include attempts at employment by immigrants in the country illegally. Maricopa County Sheriff Joe Arpaio began to enforce them. 

A group of plaintiffs challenged those laws, including a woman who was convicted of identity theft and a taxpayer in Maricopa County, which includes Phoenix. They objected to using taxpayer dollars to enforce the law. Arpaio tried to get the suit thrown out of court.

The plaintiffs argued before Campbell that the federal rule on employment applications by immigrants in the country illegally supersedes Arizona law. To resolve those challenges, Campbell took into account a 1947 U.S. Supreme Court case that says courts should assume that “the historic police powers of the states” aren’t superseded “unless that was the clear and manifest purpose of Congress.”

read more here:

Views: 730

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

Shameful of this LIBERAL Judge, he is anti-Christian / anti-United States of America Everything!!

You are correct Sister. Legally the judge cannot come against present laws without due process. He is doing this to avoid the legalities of it!. He wants Arizona to bow and they have every right to reject his decision as he did not use due process! He needs to make decisions against these laws and that takes much time. Liberals are noted not to obey the legal process to avoid the times that honorable Americans have to go through!

Never mind the "due process" NO FEDERAL  JUDGE CAN EVEN LAWFULLY BE IN ANY STATE,  MUCH LESS OPERATE IN IT IN ANY WAY. Kick the darn Federal court out or arrest the judge for just being there  plus his trying to dictate to the state and over-throw state law.  That is the same as any Foreigner trying to over=throw the govt - the state govt is being attacked there and they need to make an example of that Federal trespasser. The state laws are over any and all Federal anything that comes along - DC has  not real power = the STATES are who have the power ! Time the states take back their power and set things right and straight and put DC in its place instead of bowing to it.

Arizona, tell them to shove it! 



Yes, it is law so support what you are doing. This idiot anti-American judge has no right to tell anyone to ignore present ;laws! We know BO does all the time and this judge the same! He can climb a post like he thinks his ancestors did!

The plan is to keep wages low and continue to suppress middle class americans by flooding the country with illegal aliens who are getting welfare on top of incomes from jobs they are taking from us. They get hiring preferences for being a minority.

Things won't get better until americans understand this.

oh god he is an a** hole put in by clinton I live in PHX  idiots this man he has b een violating our laws forever!

*Edited Offensive Word, Please Re-Read the Members Rules!!*

Hang the illegals.


Right on. The judge must think that the States need to get federal approval for their laws. Like most progressives he must also view the States as mere administrative units of the NATIONAL government.





Political Cartoons by Mike LesterPolitical Cartoons by Gary Varvel

Political Cartoons by Pat Cross


New York's Green Light Law - Allows Illegal Aliens To Get Driver’s Licenses

New York passed a law to allow illegal immigrants to obtain driver’s licenses earlier this year but it was held up by challenges.

Now it is set to take effect this week.

In typical leftist fashion, supporters claim this is going to somehow make New York’s roads safer for everyone.

Could it really be about voting?

FOX News reports:

Illegal immigrants to be able to get driver’s licenses in NY after legal challenge fails.

Illegal immigrants in New York will able to obtain driver’s licenses starting next week after a last-minute legal challenge was dismissed — making it the 13th state to allow the practice, but one that critics say is unconstitutional.

The Green Light Law, signed by Democratic Gov. Andrew Cuomo earlier this year, allows anyone to apply for a driver’s license regardless of immigration status and does not require a Social Security number.

Illegal immigrants can use a combination of documents that include a valid passport from a foreign country and a valid foreign driver’s license, as long as it has been expired for less than two years.

“After waiting 18 years to have their right to drive restored, thanks to our legislature, New York can now officially join 12 other states in making driver’s licenses legally available to all residents,” New York Immigration Coalition Executive Director Steve Choi said in a statement this week, arguing that it will make roads safer and the economy stronger.

County clerks in New York have concerns and are sounding an alarm.

CBS News in Albany reports:

County clerks concerned by loopholes in Green Light law.

Undocumented immigrants now have the green light to get a driver’s license in New York…but several county clerks in the Capital Region are concerned.

Saratoga County Clerk Craig Hayner said, “We found that everything we were concerned about as far as fraud and all sorts of other things are in that bill, in that regulation and we’re very concerned.”

Hayner tells CBS6’s Lynsey Smith there are a few loopholes in the Green Light Law.

Loopholes, such as a person coming in to get their license and not having to provide their social security number.

“That could lead to criminals coming from other states, coming in and use that as a way to defraud by just simply saying they don’t have a social security number…and that’s a very dangerous loophole,” replied Hayner.

Does anyone believe this is going to make New York safer or that this is really about driving?

Delusional Democrats

© 2019   Created by Steve - Ning Creator.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service